Update from Milwaukee Personal Injury Lawyer Blog
Nursing homes grapple with dementia and ability to consent
On behalf of Milwaukee personal injury attorney Ric Domnitz of Domnitz & Domnitz, S.C. posted in Nursing Home Abuse on Thursday, December 19, 2013.
We recently wrote about nursing home abuse in our Milwaukee Personal Injury Lawyer Blog. The prior blog discussed a situation involving a staff member who was charged with sexually assaulting a resident. No sexual intercourse should be had between staff members and patients, but what about two patients who consent?
Patients are often allowed to have relationships; simply because they require assistive care doesn’t mean that they have lost the need for emotional and physical connection. However, when one or both of the patients have dementia, where does the line get drawn between the ability to consent and sexual abuse?
Take a recent case involving hospital administration that found that two patients with dementia had voluntary intercourse without the knowledge of the staff. The director of nursing and the home’s administrator discussed the situation and chose not to report it. Later, when others learned of the situation, the two were fired. The home was fined $47,000 by the Department of Inspections and Appeals for the failure to report.
When the woman’s family later filed a lawsuit against the facility, the issue of consent arose. The woman had suffered from Alzheimer’s at the time. The family said that this disease prevented her from being able to consent. The nursing home claimed that the woman had been a willing participant.
What complicates these cases even further is the fact that many people suffering from Alzheimer’s may know who they are in the morning, showing fewer signs of incapacity. As the day goes on, the individual becomes less aware, but at what point does the patient lose the ability to consent? Does the fact that the patient suffers from dementia at all eliminate the ability to consent? Should the staff always step in to stop any sexual activity and always report it when they find that it has occurred? Is this a case of failure to supervise?
The answers to these questions may vary from one situation to another. Laws that differ from one state to another can certainly affect a case as well. A Milwaukee attorney can explain how different factors may affect a case and craft an argument that ensures the rights of the patient are upheld.
Source: JournalGazette.net, “Dementia, sex worrisome mix,” Bryan Gruley, Oct. 7, 2013
If you were injured due to nursing home abuse, contact a Milwaukee personal injury attorney with Domnitz & Domnitz, S.C.